The names are all profoundly recognizable, whether they’re still playing or live on as legends. The voting spanned from April 8 to May 8, and now that the picks have been officially revealed, it’s time to argue with family and friends about who should have been selected.
MORE: SN’s NL Franchise Four | AL Franchise Four | Single-season home run records by team
Here are the selections (in alphabetical order):
Angels
Vladimir Guerrero Nolan Ryan Tim Salmon Mike Trout
Astros
Jeff Bagwell Lance Berkman Craig Biggio Nolan Ryan
Athletics
Dennis Eckersley Jimmie Foxx Rickey Henderson Reggie Jackson
Blue Jays
Roberto Alomar Joe Carter Carlos Delgado Roy Halladay
Braves
Hank Aaron Chipper Jones Greg Maddux Warren Spahn
Brewers
Cecil Cooper Rollie Fingers Paul Molitor Robin Yount
Cardinals
Lou Brock Bob Gibson Rogers Hornsby Stan Musial
Cubs
Ernie Banks Ryne Sandberg Ron Santo Billy Williams
D-backs
Paul Goldschmidt Luis Gonzalez Randy Johnson Curt Schilling
Dodgers
Don Drysdale Sandy Koufax Jackie Robinson Duke Snider
Giants
Barry Bonds Willie Mays Willie McCovey Buster Posey
Indians
Bob Feller Tris Speaker Jim Thome Omar Vizquel
Mariners
Ken Griffey Jr. Felix Hernandez Edgar Martinez Ichiro Suzuki
Marlins
Jeff Conine Mike Lowell Gary Sheffield Giancarlo Stanton
Mets
Keith Hernandez Mike Piazza Tom Seaver David Wright
Nationals/Expos
Gary Carter Andre Dawson Vladimir Guerrero Tim Raines
Orioles
Jim Palmer Cal Ripken Jr. Brooks Robinson Frank Robinson
Padres
Tony Gwynn Trevor Hoffman Randy Jones Dave Winfield
Phillies
Richie Ashburn Steve Carlton Robin Roberts Mike Schmidt
Pirates
Roberto Clemente Bill Mazeroski Willie Stargell Honus Wagner
Rangers
Adrian Beltre Ivan Rodriguez Nolan Ryan Michael Young
Rays
Evan Longoria David Price James Shields Ben Zobrist
Red Sox
Pedro Martinez David Ortiz Ted Williams Carl Yastrzemski
Reds
Johnny Bench Barry Larkin Joe Morgan Pete Rose
Rockies
Andres Galarraga Todd Helton Troy Tulowitzki Larry Walker
Royals
George Brett Dan Quisenberry Bret Saberhagen Frank White
Tigers
Miguel Cabrera Ty Cobb Hank Greenberg Al Kaline
Twins
Rod Carew Harmon Killebrew Tony Oliva Kirby Puckett
White Sox
Harold Baines Paul Konerko Minnie Minoso Frank Thomas
Yankees
Joe DiMaggio Lou Gehrig Mickey Mantle Babe Ruth
